They Built This City on Solid Gold – A Belfort Review

As Linus van Pelt once so aptly conveyed: “Happiness is a warm blanket.” There’s a lot of subtle, yet strong subtext in that sentiment; we humans often have a base desire to be wrapped tightly in comforting familiarity, and while so wrapped, have no wish to do much more than remain so, content and without need or care of the slipping of time. In certain gaming circles – and, indeed, in the Dice Hate Me household – that emotional conveyance could often be repurposed, with no loss of power or sentiment, to “happiness is a long Euro.” And, so, this is how the latest release from Tasty Minstrel Games – Belfort – has a lot in common with a hand-drawn, grade-school philosopher’s best friend.

Make no mistake – despite the whimsy of elves, dwarves and gnomes amidst a fantasy city setting on the front of the box, within Belfort beats the heart of one beast of a Euro game. This is not an untamed beast, mind you (I did mention that bit about a warm, fuzzy blanket) but it is a beast, nonetheless, and one that requires – nay, demands – commitment and attention. The benefit of this beast (and, some elite gamers might say, drawback) is that Belfort is comprised mostly of several standard Euro conventions and gaming mechanisms that only those that have never even looked sideways at a German boardgame might not recognize.

The simple and typical goal of the game is points, divvied out every couple of rounds, but getting those points is far from simple. Players must use dwarves, elves and gnomes to engage in a veritable buffet of Euro mechanisms:

  • Worker placement: Elves and dwarves make up the bulk of the Belfort workforce and they can be placed in various locations around the city to obtain resources or nab special player abilities. Gnomes can be hired later after building certain structures to act as staff for the buildings, activating even more unique abilities for a player. The interesting part of worker placement here are the planks – certain locations that contain a circle and a square, meaning they can only be used by circle-tokened elves and square-tokened dwarves – and gnome locks – which, by virtue of their nomenclature, indicate that they can only be unlocked by the pentagon-shaped gnomes. These specialized locations add a layer of extra strategy in how to hire, delegate and best utilize your workers from turn to turn.
  • Resource management: The typical Euro resources abound in the lands surrounding Belfort – wood, stone, metal and gold. However, the delineation of worker types make decisions on how to obtain them even more maddening; elves can gather wood, dwarves can gather stone, together they can gather metal, and either can gather gold. Since each resource is precious, and all are used in various combinations to construct the various buildings in the city (to net points and gain abilities), there is always more demand than your workers can supply. There is also a subtle bidding mechanic inherent in the resource area; the player who places the most workers in a particular area can take an extra resource. It’s a sneaky mechanic, but quite often the player that pays attention and makes best use of this advantage is able to eke out a point or two in other areas of the game.
  • Variable turn order: Turn order in Belfort is determined by the number rank on player crests. During the worker placement phase, players can dedicate one or more workers to the King’s Camp in an effort to take control of a certain crest. Early in the game, players may find that it’s often best to go first in order to first place their workers in Guilds or other advantageous locations around the city. However, in the last couple of rounds of play, going last has a great advantage, as that player can better react to the scoring efforts of others.
  • Hand management: Each player starts with three Property cards in their hands; these cards represent the various buildings located in each of the five districts in Belfort. The main points of the game are awarded to players who build these structures and best take control of parts of the city (we’re getting there!). Property cards are built during the action sequence of a player’s turn through the use of the above-mentioned resources. Most players will be able to build an average of one structure per turn, which means that their starting hand will slowly deplete. However, the hand limit is 5, and there are buildings and Guilds that can allow players to draw several cards in a turn, and each player has the option to pay one gold at the end of their turn in order to draw one card. Hands fill up faster than expected, always giving each player a plethora of choices for both tactics and strategy. Careful selection of the buildings (which ones will afford the best abilities, which will be most useful for scoring) is one of the most crucial decisions in the game.
  • Area control: So, those buildings you just built to give you an extra gold each turn, or produce gnomes more cheaply? Those same buildings are your main source of points in Belfort. After exchanging resources to construct a Property, a player takes one of their little wooden Monopoly houses (well, that’s what they are) and places it on top of any building with the corresponding icon in any of the five districts that does not already contain a wooden Monopoly house from another player. During scoring rounds (rounds 3, 5 and 7), the player with the most Properties in a particular district is awarded a whopping 5 points (believe me, that’s huge), the second-most Properties gains 3 points and 3rd place gets 1. Players tied for any position both gain the points for the next-highest scoring level. There is often quite a bit of jockeying during scoring rounds (naturally), and Belfort contains mechanisms and Properties that can allow players to sneakily wrest control of a district from others when they least expect it. This demands concentration, quite a bit of planning and just a bit of luck, but the look on an opponent’s face is worth every ounce of energy.

As any of you dear readers can see, Belfort has a lot of parts to that beastly Euro heart. If that’s all there was to offer, there’s a possibility a few gamers might get bored. But allow me to elaborate before you all strike up the yawns.

Gnomes! Very helpful and very much a pain.

To begin, variability of play in Belfort is astounding. Each game, a certain mix of Basic, Resource and Interactive Guilds are placed in the five districts of the city. When a worker is placed on a Guild, the player pays a gold coin to the city and can then activate special abilities, such as recruiting more workers (Elves and Dwarves) to collecting a boatload of stone or wood from the supply, to stealing Gold from another player. Players are also able to exchange resources in order to take control of the Guilds, taking money from any player that choose to use the Guild’s ability.

Scoring can also be influenced by sources other than Property cards. Players can build Walls in a district through the use of resources and without the use of a Property card. These walls can often be used to disrupt or take control of a district for a higher score. This is also true of taking control of Guilds. Players may also influence scoring through the use of worker majority. Those players who have the most Elves, Dwarves or Gnomes in their employ during scoring rounds will vastly improve their standings.

Needless to say, choices abound, so Belfort is not for the attention-deficit crowd, nor is it for those looking for a quick hit. To employ yet another simile, Belfort is like a well-crafted novel that you just don’t want to put down; it may be difficult to convince yourself to start, but by the time you’ve reached the end, you don’t want the story or experience to come to an end. As I mentioned before, some gamers may complain that there is too much familiarity, that Belfort contains too many well-trod Euro game staples; to that I say that it is the whole sum of these familiar parts that weaves the welcoming and comforting blanket that is Belfort.

Gameplay/ReplayComponents & ThemeFun
For those already firmly acquainted with modern Euro games, delving directly into gameplay in Belfort shouldn't pose much of a problem. That being said, however, even those gamers that consider themselves a master of the fine gaming arts will find challenge and depth through the myriad tough decisions and multiple scoring avenues. For those players that have not been inducted into the Euro fold, it's inevitable that Belfort be compared to accessible Euro classics such as Stone Age and Fresco; however, as accessible as Belfort's individual mechanics may be, I would strongly consider it a great step above those aforementioned games in complexity and depth of decisions. As for replay, the use of variable Guilds, the broad mix of Property cards and the multitude of possible strategies and shifting tactical priorities puts Belfort in an elite category. Any day of the week, elves, dwarves and gnomes trump dour 16th-century noblemen, or 17th-century farmers and traders on the front of the box. For that reason alone, Belfort could score a five on the Dice Hate Me scale. The bump to a six is courtesy of Josh Cappel's amazing artistic stylings and clean, yet whimsical, graphic design. The art, coupled with the fantastical theme and fantastic components, combine to form a perfect storm of immersive and colorful visuals that will appeal across a wide array of players and demographics. There are an awful lot of thinky things in Belfort; for many gamers, that will be akin to the time of their lives, but for the average gamer, that will equal a fair bit of stress and slightly-uncomfortable decision-making. For that reason alone, Belfort fails to score perfectly on the Fun scale. Some gamers will find walking the razor's edge between total point domination and total point demolition to be as fun and exciting as can be; for others, they'll simply revel in the small joys of having more dwarves to do their bidding than others. That's not to say that Belfort isn't fun - when any player saunters into town looking for just the right mix of Euro and social styling, they'll be in for a very special treat.
Overall score: 17 out of 18 - Definitely not your average deck-builder or dice-roller, but if you’d love nothing better than to dig into a heaping helping of Euro goodness - and would prefer your game boxes be not adorned by dour 16th-century tradesmen - then Belfort is worth the time. And as for just a little hint: Belfort is in the running for Dice Hate Me Game of the Year. It's that good.

Belfort is a game for 2-5 fantastical civil engineers, ages 12 and up, by Sen-Foong Lim and Jay Cormier for Tasty Minstrel Games. It retails for $59.99 (but there’s a lot in the box!) Word from a reliable source states that TMG is sold out of the 1st edition of Belfort, so if you’d like to get a copy, check online or at your FLGS as soon as you can!

Related posts:

  1. They Built This City…
  2. I’ve Been Drinking on the Railroad – A TransEuropa Review
  3. A Few Fries Short of a Happy Meal – A Burger Joint Review
  4. The Amazing Race – A Travel Blog review
  5. Unearthing Treasure: A Pergamon Review
10 Responses to “They Built This City on Solid Gold – A Belfort Review”
  1. tomg says:

    Excellent review. I agree. This is a deceivingly deep game with a great amount of strategy. You reminded me of two rules that we have forgotten and that will make it even more strategic. I can’t wait to play it with more than two. How about after Macao at MACE?

  2. Marc Specter says:

    I have played this game 3 times–AND LOST EACH TIME!!! And yet I am drawn back. That was a great review, and I wholeheartedly agree that the whole is greater than the sum of its parts in this case. This is a fantastic game experience, and I am eager to bring it out again. Huge kudos to TMG.

  3. I have my fingers crossed for the Game of the Year per Dice Hate Me. I want some screaming dice on the cover!

  4. Paul Owen says:

    I’ll be looking for answers to these questions on boardgamegeek, but I’d like to get your take on these:
    1. It sounds similar in depth, complexity, and enjoyment to Agricola. Is that a fair comparison?
    2. Does it work with two players? (Very important to me – most of my games are with my wife.)

  5. Stephen Avery says:

    “in the Dice Hate Me household – that emotional conveyance could often be repurposed, with no loss of power or sentiment, to “happiness is a long Euro.”

    Thats it. I’m coming to burn your house and rape your dog.


  6. dicehateme says:

    Tom – I got a chance to play at MACE, but wish you and I had a chance to play it, as well. We’ll get together soon for it!

    Marc – I’ve won once, and all but one have been super tight. The last one, though, Shawn blitzed us all with a worker recruitment strategy. Brutal! Need to find a way to combat that one.

    Michael – Keep those fingers crossed – if Belfort ends up being the one, I’d love to see some screaming dice on that cover!

    Steve – Calm down, man… Twilight Imperium is practically our coffee table, and I’m going to be buried with HeroQuest, so I don’t want to hear it.

  7. dicehateme says:

    Paul – I would say that Belfort stacks up to Agricola, although they are different breeds. Belfort is just as thinky, but feels a bit more breezy and smooth. Agricola is a great game, but I would prefer to play Belfort. I hope they offer an expansion of sorts to add some new building twists and guilds to the mix. As for it working well with two, I would say yes. Cherilyn and I have really enjoyed our two-player experience with it, and the dummy player mechanic is very elegant.

Check out what others are saying...
  1. […] excellent gaming site Dice Hate Me just posted this glowing review of Belfort, rating it in terms of Gameplay/Reply, Components & Theme, and […]

  2. […] Belfort is a game for 2-5 fantastical civil engineers, ages 12 and up, by Sen-Foong Lim and Jay Cormier for Tasty Minstrel Games. […]

I Value Your Opinion - Please Leave A Comment